Abstract of Essays I Don’t Have Time to Write 2: Michael Schur’s New Sincerity

Following the release of the final season of The Good Place, Jonathan Compo reflects on showrunner Michael Schur’s career. 

Photo by Frederick M. Brown - © 2014 Getty Images - Image courtesy gettyimages.com

Michael Schur’s trilogy—The Office (US), Parks and Recreation, and The Good Place—are an attempt to recuperate New Sincerity. This is bad.

To understand why this is bad, we need to make a deal: I’ll give you the definitions of recuperation and New Sincerity, as I understand them, and you will entertain for a moment, regardless of what you believe I.R.L., that capitalism is a gigantic, blood-sucking squid, and television one of that squid’s many blood-sucking tentacles. Deal? O.K.

1: Recuperation: “the process by which politically radical ideas and images are twisted, co-opted, annexed and commodified within media culture and thus become neutralized.” It’s pretty straightforward.

2: New Sincerity, according to David Foster Wallace’s essay, “E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction:” 

The new rebels

The next real literary "rebels" in this country might well emerge as some weird bunch of anti-rebels, born oglers who dare somehow to back away from ironic watching, who have the childish gall actually to endorse and instantiate single-entendre principles. Who treat of plain old untrendy human troubles and emotions in U.S. life with reverence and conviction. Who eschew self-consciousness and hip fatigue ...

The new rebels might be artists willing to risk the yawn, the rolled eyes, the cool smile, the nudged ribs, the parody of gifted ironists, the "Oh how banal.” To risk accusations of sentimentality, melodrama. Of overcredulity. Of softness. Of willingness to be suckered by a world of lurkers and starers who fear gaze and ridicule above imprisonment without law. Who knows.

The idea is that in response to too-much “metafictional and self-conscious irony in contemporary” media, a new literary movement would arise and embrace a “new sincerity.” 

The David Foster Wallace essay is important for two reasons. One, Michael Schur is obsessed with the guy. This lends credibility to a connection between the writer’s ethos and the showrunner’s. I can practically guarantee you that Michael Schur has read “E Unibus Pluram.” The second important thing is the essay’s subtitle: “Television and U.S. Fiction.” “E Unibus Pluram,” which kicked off the New Sincerity movement, is an essay about how books could respond to the threat posed by television. 

Okay, so here’s the thesis: Michael Schur, a sucker on the televisual arm of late capitalism, has taken an ethos designed to help fiction fight TV, and recuperated it. His shows, expanding from a single office to a local government to the entire cosmos, present New Sincerity as the only way to survive our soul-murdering capitalist reality. Sincerity, in Schur’s vision, exists not as an escape hatch from this reality, or as a hammer with which to break it apart, but as a feature of it. It offers sentimentality as a participation trophy to the revolution’s losers. Being nice won’t get you anywhere, Schur’s shows say, but boy, isn’t it still awful nice? 

The rest of this essay will explain precisely how Schur’s shows go about recuperating New Sincerity, how this action expands with each new show, and what exactly is lost when the TV gets sincere. 

 

Read also: Abstracts of Essays I Don’t Have Time to Write 1: John Green’s Fear 

Donate

Comments

Find us at

Twitter Facebook Instagram RSS Flipboard

Share This Article!

Like this article?

Tags

Michael Schur David Foster Wallace New Sincerity The Office Parks and Recreation The Good Place E Unibus Pluram Recuperation Season 4 Sentimentality Hope literature TV

Donate

We Recommend

Related stories

3 Best Shows To Stream While You Are At Home

3 Best Shows To Stream While You Are At Home

Insecure On HBO Max If you are looking for a mix of drama and comedy, stream Insecure on HBO Max. The series, based on Issa Rae’s web series Awkward Black Girl, follows Issa Dee (played by Issa Rae herself) as she navigates…

Read more trending_flat
British Comedy-Drama “The Duke” To Premiere At Venice Film Festival

British Comedy-Drama “The Duke” To Premiere At Venice Film Festival

British comedy-drama “The Duke” will have its world premiere at the 2020 Venice Film Festival.  The film stars Oscar-winning duo Jim Broadbent and Helen Mirren, and cast members include Fionn Whitehead, Matthew…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Strangled Amber Heard On Their Honeymoon, She Claims

Johnny Depp Strangled Amber Heard On Their Honeymoon, She Claims

Amber Heard was back in the witness box to give evidence in the libel trial against The Sun. Heard is The Sun’s star witness and is in court to defend her accusations of domestic violence against Johnny Depp.  The Sun’s…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Held Amber Heard “Hostage” In Australia, She Claims

Johnny Depp Held Amber Heard “Hostage” In Australia, She Claims

On Tuesday Amber Heard and Johnny Depp reconvened at High Court to proceed with the libel trial against The Sun. Heard took to the witness stand for the second time as The Sun’s star witness, defending her accusations of Depp’s…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Created A “Monster” Persona, Claims Amber Heard 

Johnny Depp Created A “Monster” Persona, Claims Amber Heard 

On the 10th day of the libel trial against The Sun, Amber Heard took to the witness stand for the first time to give evidence. Though Johnny Depp sued the newspaper for calling him a “wife-beater,” the trial quickly escalated…

Read more trending_flat
Winona Ryder And Vanessa Paradis Vouch For Johnny Depp 

Winona Ryder And Vanessa Paradis Vouch For Johnny Depp 

Eight days into the libel trial against The Sun, the court heard that Amber Heard punched Johnny Depp after the couple got into an argument at her birthday party. On Thursday, two of Depp’s security personnel served as witnesses…

Read more trending_flat

Latest article

Top