Abstracts of Essays I Don’t Have Time to Write 1: John Green’s Fear 

Following the release of the Looking for Alaska Hulu series, Jonathan Compo reflects on the book Looking for Alaska.

Photo: Gage Skidmore

John Green—author, philanthropist, self-identified nerd and YouTube mogul—is afraid of women. This isn’t apparent from his vlogbrothers videos, his Anthropocene Reviewed podcast, his two most recent novels, or in his charitable ventures, but it is the central fault in the book that made his name, Looking for Alaska, and in Paper Towns, a book which, if Green were an Updike disciple instead of Wallace’s, would have been called Alaska Redux.

This essay will focus on Paper Towns. Looking for Alaska, as most debuts are, is disfigured by its desire to exist, too disfigured for it to be doing anything or about anything in the way an author’s later work may be. The inherent struggle of any first book is am I to write? And this question almost always poisons the thematic unity of that first book. In this way, though, first novels are freed from the considerations that haunt mature artists, and may therefore approach something like truth, irreducible and impossible to parse. Maybe Alaska is not beyond criticism, but it’s beyond the abilities of this critic.

Paper Towns smell of fear

 Paper Towns, though, I can criticize. Towns, an explicit response to Alaska, attempts to rectify the charges against the former novel, is so concerned with this rectification it risks becoming about redeeming the author from his past sins rather than about its characters, is entombed in ideological and pragmatic considerations that threaten its existence as a work of art and make tenuous its connection to anything like truth. Paper Towns smells of fear. Smells of a fear, specifically, of misrepresenting its female lead, Margo Roth Spiegalman.             

To criticize Towns though, we must circle back to Alaska. John Green views his early novels as engaged in the work of ‘deromanticization.’ In Alaska, he makes gross those teenage firsts meant to be rosy: first love, first kiss, first blowjob. He in that book, however, in the eyes of some critics and for reasons suggested above, fails and ends up romanticizing the character Alaska. She is, some argue, idealized and idealized specifically for her flaws and her mental illness (mental illness is often listed as a subcategory of flaw; let’s be very clear that’s not true). 

Margo Roth Spiegalman exists to deromanticize the Alaska archetype, the Depressed Damsel. This contemporary revision of the Damsel in Distress exists for the same purpose: to be found. John Green, in an attempt to take apart this idea, creates in Margo someone who exists only to not be found. Taking apart this idea is a good goal, and Paper Towns is a good attempt at achieving it. But, for guilt or for fear, Green falls short. To make a point soundly, one must give the most charitable possible picture of the other side, and, for guilt of for fear, Green does not. Paper Towns refuses to acknowledge in Margo the universal desire to be located, and by doing so undermines its point and Margo’s humanity. Paper Towns doesn’t fully acknowledge that sometimes we all want to be found. 

 

Donate

Comments

Find us at

Twitter Facebook Instagram RSS Flipboard

Share This Article!

Like this article?

Tags

John Green Looking for Alaska Hulu Paper Towns Feminism Manic Pixie Dream Girl Damsel in Distress

Donate

We Recommend

Related stories

3 Best Shows To Stream While You Are At Home

3 Best Shows To Stream While You Are At Home

Insecure On HBO Max If you are looking for a mix of drama and comedy, stream Insecure on HBO Max. The series, based on Issa Rae’s web series Awkward Black Girl, follows Issa Dee (played by Issa Rae herself) as she navigates…

Read more trending_flat
British Comedy-Drama “The Duke” To Premiere At Venice Film Festival

British Comedy-Drama “The Duke” To Premiere At Venice Film Festival

British comedy-drama “The Duke” will have its world premiere at the 2020 Venice Film Festival.  The film stars Oscar-winning duo Jim Broadbent and Helen Mirren, and cast members include Fionn Whitehead, Matthew…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Strangled Amber Heard On Their Honeymoon, She Claims

Johnny Depp Strangled Amber Heard On Their Honeymoon, She Claims

Amber Heard was back in the witness box to give evidence in the libel trial against The Sun. Heard is The Sun’s star witness and is in court to defend her accusations of domestic violence against Johnny Depp.  The Sun’s…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Held Amber Heard “Hostage” In Australia, She Claims

Johnny Depp Held Amber Heard “Hostage” In Australia, She Claims

On Tuesday Amber Heard and Johnny Depp reconvened at High Court to proceed with the libel trial against The Sun. Heard took to the witness stand for the second time as The Sun’s star witness, defending her accusations of Depp’s…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Created A “Monster” Persona, Claims Amber Heard 

Johnny Depp Created A “Monster” Persona, Claims Amber Heard 

On the 10th day of the libel trial against The Sun, Amber Heard took to the witness stand for the first time to give evidence. Though Johnny Depp sued the newspaper for calling him a “wife-beater,” the trial quickly escalated…

Read more trending_flat
Winona Ryder And Vanessa Paradis Vouch For Johnny Depp 

Winona Ryder And Vanessa Paradis Vouch For Johnny Depp 

Eight days into the libel trial against The Sun, the court heard that Amber Heard punched Johnny Depp after the couple got into an argument at her birthday party. On Thursday, two of Depp’s security personnel served as witnesses…

Read more trending_flat

Latest article

Top