Abstracts of Essays I Don’t Have Time to Write 3: Women Recommend Misogynists to Me

The diminishment of certain male authors after #MeToo has inspired a defense, Jonathan Compo writes, and many of these defenders are women.

Vladimir Nabokov

The absolute value and relative importance of a given book is forever being reassessed. For those with a stake in one book, though, this reassessment appears a personal threat, as the inexorable advance of the tide appears to a child architect of a sandcastle. And so, the diminishment of certain totemic male authors in the wake of, among other things, #MeToo, has inspired a defense. From The New York Review of Books, The New Yorker, The Paris Review, The TLS and elsewhere, horns have been blown. What distinguishes this wave from others before is many of these defenders are women. 

My cynical read is this: when a once-beloved author comes under fire from my etiquette-minded generation and is accused of portraying women’s insides too little and their outsides too much or of having mistreated the real women in the author’s life, those looking to defend him (and it’s always him) are in a bind. Send a male writer after the PC complainers, and you open your publication up to the same criticism—you are perpetuating Literature as Boy’s Club. So, you find a female fan and have her make the case. 

Here’s a game

I’ve read defenses from women of Nabokov, Lawrence, Updike, Eliot, Wallace, Tolstoy, Bloom, Kerouac, Roth and—for god’s sake—Eminem. Here’s a game. Think of a problematic author (this should be easy), google “In Defense of [insert author’s name],” and once you filter through all the lit-bro blog posts, you’ll find an eloquent and profound article in the following form: acknowledge the ethical criticism of the author, state your identity credentials, and then defend the author on the basis of aesthetics. 

You’ll quickly realize, playing this game, there are few male authors who weren’t objective assholes to women in their lives and in their books. Two, even given this, it’s hard to refute the defenses offered in the kind of article I’m describing. You can always, after all, trust a misogynist for a fancy prose style.

Economy of attention

Their formal invention, their facility with words and their resulting importance to The Canon™ are the grounds on which these authors are defended. Sure. Fine. But I’m left uneasy. I don’t want to rewrite history, and I’m not, I don’t think, an opponent of beauty—but I’m suspicious, in this economy of attention, of any extra attention paid to authors from people who those authors consciously, if ironically, routinely disregarded. Why spend time defending the reputation of the intentionally disreputable?

Also, I am skeptical that any art, no matter how gorgeous, can fully account for its artist’s failures. This is a sliding scale, sure—I’m not trying to scoop every author who’s abused the c-word in with those who’ve pushed their partners out of moving cars—but there are those who I just can’t read anymore without recalling the Camp Cope lyrics:

Could it be true?
You don't seem like that kind of guy
Not you, you've got that one song that I like
They said he's got one song that I like


 

Donate

Comments

Find us at

Twitter Facebook Instagram RSS Flipboard

Share This Article!

Like this article?

Tags

Nabokov Lawrence Updike Eliot Wallace Tolstoy Bloom Kerouac Roth Eminem The New York Review of Books The New Yorker The Paris Review The TLS Canon literature

Donate

We Recommend

Related stories

3 Best Shows To Stream While You Are At Home

3 Best Shows To Stream While You Are At Home

Insecure On HBO Max If you are looking for a mix of drama and comedy, stream Insecure on HBO Max. The series, based on Issa Rae’s web series Awkward Black Girl, follows Issa Dee (played by Issa Rae herself) as she navigates…

Read more trending_flat
British Comedy-Drama “The Duke” To Premiere At Venice Film Festival

British Comedy-Drama “The Duke” To Premiere At Venice Film Festival

British comedy-drama “The Duke” will have its world premiere at the 2020 Venice Film Festival.  The film stars Oscar-winning duo Jim Broadbent and Helen Mirren, and cast members include Fionn Whitehead, Matthew…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Strangled Amber Heard On Their Honeymoon, She Claims

Johnny Depp Strangled Amber Heard On Their Honeymoon, She Claims

Amber Heard was back in the witness box to give evidence in the libel trial against The Sun. Heard is The Sun’s star witness and is in court to defend her accusations of domestic violence against Johnny Depp.  The Sun’s…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Held Amber Heard “Hostage” In Australia, She Claims

Johnny Depp Held Amber Heard “Hostage” In Australia, She Claims

On Tuesday Amber Heard and Johnny Depp reconvened at High Court to proceed with the libel trial against The Sun. Heard took to the witness stand for the second time as The Sun’s star witness, defending her accusations of Depp’s…

Read more trending_flat
Johnny Depp Created A “Monster” Persona, Claims Amber Heard 

Johnny Depp Created A “Monster” Persona, Claims Amber Heard 

On the 10th day of the libel trial against The Sun, Amber Heard took to the witness stand for the first time to give evidence. Though Johnny Depp sued the newspaper for calling him a “wife-beater,” the trial quickly escalated…

Read more trending_flat
Winona Ryder And Vanessa Paradis Vouch For Johnny Depp 

Winona Ryder And Vanessa Paradis Vouch For Johnny Depp 

Eight days into the libel trial against The Sun, the court heard that Amber Heard punched Johnny Depp after the couple got into an argument at her birthday party. On Thursday, two of Depp’s security personnel served as witnesses…

Read more trending_flat

Latest article

Top