Don’t Worry About The Deficit From Fighting Coronavirus

Recent stimulus measures have reawakened controversy over the national debt. Liam Glen writes on the federal deficit and why fighting the pandemic is worth spending trillions of dollars.

Don’t Worry About The Deficit From Fighting Coronavirus

The US government is sparing no expense in combating the COVID-19 pandemic. Congress has recently passed a $2 trillion stimulus deal to prevent economic collapse, and there may be more of such bills to come.

But this massive expenditure has reawakened concerns about the national debt, which currently sits at over $23 trillion. Democratic and Republican leaders alike have adopted a blasé attitude towards the issue, but there is still a small subsection who remain deeply worried about deficit spending.

Some have even suggested that the looming peril of future debt is a greater concern than the current threat of COVID-19. Famed political cartoonist Michael Ramirez attracted mockery for presenting the COVID-19 pandemic as paling by comparison to the debt “epidemic” (not realizing that a pandemic is, by definition, worse than an epidemic). But the concern is widespread enough that it is worth interrogating the possible impacts of this massive expenditure.

How Much Does the Deficit Matter?

An important caveat when answering questions like this is that macroeconomics – despite its emphasis on complex quantitative models – is not an exact science.

To study COVID-19, for instance, doctors can see how it affects different patients in a controlled environment. Economists have no such ability. They can observe periods of boom and bust, crisis and prosperity, but they cannot determine the underlying causes with absolute certainty. For this reason, scholars often disagree about the fundamental principles of how the economy works.

That being said, many of us are accustomed to viewing national spending as similar to a household budget. Our income must always exceed our expenditures. If we do owe any money, we must pay it off as soon as possible lest we face dire consequences. This is often portrayed as an ominous, nigh-apocalyptic event – the day our grandchildren will pay for our reckless spending. The reality, however, is more complicated.

The US government, which oversees the largest economy in the history of the world, works differently from a typical household. When it runs a deficit, it makes it up by issuing out treasury bonds, on which it pays interest. However, there is no obligation to ever pay back the entire thing. The federal government has been in debt for the near-entirety of its existence. The amount of debt has increased over time, but so has the size of the overall economy.

The long-term impact of this is uncertain. But economists generally agree that running too high a deficit for too long can be highly problematic. More bonds lead to higher interest rates, which hurt economic growth and lead to lower wages. If investors start losing confidence in the US government, there is a chance (albeit a remote one) that it would precipitate a financial crisis comparable to the one seen in Greece.

But that does not mean that a country should run balanced budgets all the time. Keynesian economic thought, which has been dominant for much of the last century, advocates a countercyclical approach.

When the economy is good, the government should aim for balanced budgets to keep interest rates low. During recessions, however, the time comes for tax cuts and deficit spending to put more money in the hands of middle- and working-class people and stimulate the economy. As is often said in economics, “one person's spending is another person's income.”

The Scale of the Crisis

The question is whether the current crisis is severe enough to justify largescale expenditures. And the answer is an unambiguous yes. A number of conservative economists have come out in favor of stimulus measures. Both the right-wing Heritage Foundation and the Committee for a Responsible Budget criticize specific parts of Congress’s coronavirus response but acknowledge the overall need for deficit spending.

Allowing businesses to fail and Americans to lose their jobs on such a massive scale without government aid would precipitate an economic crisis far more harmful than adding a few extra trillion dollars to the national debt would. Meanwhile, the idea of ending restrictions and allowing the economy to re-open in the middle of a pandemic has the potential to cause mass death while creating an even greater economic meltdown.

Meanwhile, among the many arguments in favor of the stimulus is that the cost is not as great as it first appears. Unlike government departments and agencies like the CMS and the Pentagon which require funding every year, this is just a one-time expenditure. The deficit will spike in 2020, but it can return to normal as soon as the pandemic is under control.

The deficit is an issue which may merit consideration. But massive spending has presented itself as the only option in this time of crisis. The long-term nature of debt means that it can be addressed later.


 

 


 

*** Follow The Pavlovic Today on Twitter @pavlovictoday

Share This!

Tags

Coronavirus COVID-19 economy deficit national debt CARES Act

Like this article?

Comments

Related stories

Today I Graduated Into An Uncertain World

Today I Graduated Into An Uncertain World

The symphony of congratulations for the 2020 graduates around the world are not just for us, they are for all those who made those countless individual journeys through spaces of learning and education possible: facilities workers,…

Read more trending_flat
Exonerating Steve King Accelerates The Normalization Of White Supremacy

Exonerating Steve King Accelerates The Normalization Of White Supremacy

In early 2019, controversial Republican Congressman Steve King from Iowa’s 4th district was interviewed by the New York Times, where among other comments he said, “White nationalist, white supremacist, Western civilization…

Read more trending_flat
Why Race Is A Factor During The COVID-19 Pandemic

Why Race Is A Factor During The COVID-19 Pandemic

Race plays a significant role in this crisis, as the pandemic disproportionately affects people of color, disproportionately immigrants, who often play the vital roles of minimum wage workers that many depend on. Under twenty percent…

Read more trending_flat
Essential Workers At High Risk During COVID-19 Pandemic

Essential Workers At High Risk During COVID-19 Pandemic

Minimum wage and essential workers have no choice but to be on the front lines of the COVID-19 battle. Right now, most of the country relies on them for everything that is necessary during the COVID-19 pandemic — food, toilet…

Read more trending_flat
Electoral College Math May Distort Which States Get Coronavirus Aid

Electoral College Math May Distort Which States Get Coronavirus Aid

The federal response to COVID-19 has, to say the least, left room for improvement. To be fair, no country’s strategy has been perfect, but the US response has been particularly marked by chaos and uncertainty. Most concerning…

Read more trending_flat
Coronavirus Stimulus Package Has Some Glaring Omissions

Coronavirus Stimulus Package Has Some Glaring Omissions

As COVID-19 undermines the economy, Americans are anxious about how it will impact their ability to pay the bills. In response, Congress has passed the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act. It contains many provisions,…

Read more trending_flat

Latest article

Top