Trump’s Incoherence Is Causing Devastation In Syria

As Turkish forces invade northeastern Syria, President Trump continues to flip-flop between concern and indifference. Liam Glen writes on the consequences of his actions and rhetoric.

Photo by D. Myles Cullen

When President Donald Trump announced his surprise decision to withdraw US troops from northeastern Syria, he should have known the massive stakes of the issue. Yet, as with most issues of his presidency, the response has been confused, with key developments largely coming from Twitter.

To his credit, the president has shown some concern over the Turkish invasion of the Kurdish-majority region, currently controlled by the US-allied Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF).

This includes a threat to “totally destroy and obliterate the Economy of Turkey” and a bizarre letter to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan including the line “Don’t be a tough guy. Don’t be a fool!”

However, he has also defended his withdrawal by denigrating the SDF. He downplayed their alliance by the US by pointing out that they did not fight in World War II. While true, this is hardly something on which to base current geopolitical decisions.

In more recent history, according to The Atlantic, the SDF suffered 11,000 casualties in the fight against ISIS, compared to only five by US forces.

Trump also repeatedly described the Kurds as “not angels,” again showing his willingness to characterize entire ethnic groups by simple adjectives.

All of this culminated with a meltdown during a meeting on the issue with Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer.  It is evident that the president is incapable of clear thinking on the subject, and it is having dire consequences.

The Anti-War Façade

Trump has tried to frame his decision as deescalating conflict in the Middle East, but this ignores the reality of the situation. He is not bringing home the 1,000 US troops in Syria, but simply re-deploying 50 in northern Syria to make room for the Turkish invasion.

Around the same time, his administration has assigned 1,800 new troops to Saudi Arabia. If the SDF are not angels, one can only imagine what adjectives would be appropriate for the Saudi leadership.

US intervention is usually criticized for vainly seeking to create democratic institutions from scratch in other countries. But the residents of northern Syria have already built a functioning society. US troops are not engaging in wanton nation-building, but rather lending support to an ally.

Built on principles of secularism and gender equality, the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria is the perfect bulwark against terrorism and sectarianism in the region. But as President Trump flubs his justifications for withdrawal, the Turkish invasion, led by the Islamist Erdoğan, continues.

The Turkish government has a long history of human rights abuses against the Kurdish population within its borders, including a brutal campaign against rebels between 2015 and 2016 that largely targeted civilians.

Already, Turkish-backed jihadist forces in Syria have been accused of human rights violations including the execution of nine civilians. Among the dead was politician Hevrin Khalaf, known for her advocacy of Arab and Christian minorities in the region.

Facing the Consequences

It is clear that neither Trump nor Erdoğan expected such a large backlash from their actions. Now, however, fear of potential consequences may be enough to make them change course.

Republican lawmakers are usually unflinching in their defense of Trump’s controversies, but this only works so long as he is advancing their policy agenda. The betrayal of a US ally, creating a power vacuum that benefits Bashar Al-Assad, Vladimir Putin, and Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, is a step too far for many.

Trump ally Lindsey Graham promised to become the president’s “worst nightmare” if he does not stand up for the SDF. While impeachment proceedings are drawing the parties further apart, a supermajority in the House of Representatives voted to condemn the withdrawal.

It is thankful that Trump has a propensity for flip-flopping, as it is not too late for him to make true on his threats to punish Turkish actions. If he takes real steps to end the invasion, it could save countless lives. But it must be remembered that this entire crisis would not have happened in the first place if not for his impulsive and incoherent foreign policy.

 

 

Comments

Find us at

Twitter RSS Flipboard

Share This Article!

Like this article?

Tags

Donald Trump Erdogan foreign policy Kurdistan Rojava Syria Turkey

Related stories

The State Of The Israel-Palestine Conflict

The State Of The Israel-Palestine Conflict

Who is involved? The conflict consists of the Jewish people of Israel, the majority Muslim population in Palestine, British imperialists, and measures taken by international organizations such as the UN. Currently, the people of…

Read more trending_flat
White Privilege: What You Benefit From, That Others Do Not

White Privilege: What You Benefit From, That Others Do Not

In the world we live in, there are certain people who will always have a leg up on you, they will always have an advantage. Those people who we consider to have more of an advantage in society, are what we call privileged people. Is…

Read more trending_flat
All About Gen Z’s Struggle With Mental Health 

All About Gen Z’s Struggle With Mental Health 

Gen Z is and will always be different from any other generation who has come before us. A major way we are different from Gen Xers or Baby Boomers is that we are not afraid to advocate for ourselves and open up about the mental health…

Read more trending_flat
Memorial Day 2021: We must extend our love and memory to every casualty

Memorial Day 2021: We must extend our love and memory to every casualty

When I was a child I knew Memorial Day as a day of fun. The seemingly random day off from school meant barbecues, beach days, and plenty of sunbathing. My family spent each year decked out in our summer best to party with friends.  Then…

Read more trending_flat
Memorial Day 2021:  I Will Honor Those Who Died For Me And Every American

Memorial Day 2021: I Will Honor Those Who Died For Me And Every American

All my life I have had an appreciation for Memorial Day. Almost everyone that I know in my family has served in the military, from my father to my cousins, to my grandfather. I was taught at a young age to respect those who lay down…

Read more trending_flat
Does Roman Protasevich’s Arrest Mean Freedom Of Speech Is At Risk? 

Does Roman Protasevich’s Arrest Mean Freedom Of Speech Is At Risk? 

On Sunday, a Ryanair plane flying from Greece to Lithuania was forced to land in Minsk, where Belarusian journalist Raman Protasevich, former editor of Telegram channels Nexta and Nexta Live, was arrested. Passengers aboard the plane…

Read more trending_flat

Latest article

Top