What Does The American Dream Mean to Me?

No version of an American dream was ever a reality for marginalized Americans. Ava DeSantis writes why the decline of the fictional American dream might give way to a real, socialist one.

Photo: AdobeStock.com

Young people lucky enough to attend high school and college with relatively little financial hardship for them or their families often never experience the dismantling of the fictional ‘American dream,’ often experienced at a young age for members of marginalized communities. 

Millennials, however, will be the first generation not to exceed the wealth or job status of their parents. They have lower homeownership rates than previous generations, especially Black and Latino Millennials.

David Grusky, a sociology professor at Stanford, argued that the end of generational improvement in living standards is a failure of the American dream. “A big part of the American dream is that each generation will do better than the one that preceded it. That has been part of what’s supposed to make this country special and distinctive. When it’s just a coin flip, we’re not living up to that commitment. It’s a pretty fundamental part of what we say this country can deliver, and we’re not.” 

I disagree. This is not the death of the ‘American dream,’ which under capitalism promises Americans they will move up within the existing socio-economic hierarchy, this is an opportunity to create a non-fiction American dream. Socialism, an idea of recent interest to many young Americans, is a system of political economy under which the workers would control the means of production, as opposed to selling their labor to a capitalist class. To embrace socialism in America would allow all citizens to prosper without relying on the oppression of other citizens, and would bypass the major negative externalities of the profit motive--most importantly, climate change.

To clarify: socialism has many different meanings to many different leftists. Since Das Kapital was published in 1867, the left has debated which form of socialism or communism is preferable. Many conservatives critique proponents of socialism by citing examples like Venezuela, Maoist China, or the Soviet Union, saying these failures are evidence that socialism can only lead to “little or no economic growth, hunger, authoritarian government,” and “people risking their lives to flee.” In these cases, they confuse state capitalism with democratic socialism. State capitalism is an economic system under which private capitalism is modified by an increased amount of state ownership and control of resources. Simply put, under state capitalism the state owns the means of production. Under socialism, the workers own the means of production. It is true that state-capitalism can lead to tyrannical ends, like private, free capitalism because a small number of powerful individuals control the majority of resources and wealth in the nation. It is exactly this power dynamic that socialism overthrows.

On social mobility and freedom from oppression

 For working-class people, the economic success story of ‘rags to riches’ or ‘pulling yourself up by your bootstraps,’ was always false. 70% of Americans born into poor families will never make it to the middle class. Less than 10% of people born poor will ever make it into the top economic quantile. Even for middle-class Americans, with more access to basic necessities and adequate schooling, upward mobility is still unlikely. Only 20% of the middle-class economic quantile will make it into the top quantile. This is not a new phenomenon, as Harvard economist Raj Chetty explains “social mobility is low and has been for at least thirty or forty years.” Real mobility for most Americans can never be a reality under capitalism because the wealthy are invested financially in the oppression of working people. So, it’s no surprise that cases of mobility are individual incidents of working-class people hitting the jackpot, with an idea, a successful career, or the literal jackpot.

At least, for the working-class white family, a less ambitious version of the American dream might mean freedom from direct government oppression, like obscene restrictions on bodily autonomy or freedom of speech, or uncalled-for violence. For Americans of color, even this marginal freedom was always a myth.  

As Black Lives Matter activists repeated for years, Black men in America are 3.5 times more likely than whites to die at the hands of law enforcement, statistically, 1 in every 1,000 black men will die due to police force. Black Americans are not free from direct and violent state oppression.

A shift in public opinion

49.5% of Gen Z and Millennial Americans say they would prefer to live in a socialist country, as opposed to a capitalist one. 73.2% believe the government should provide universal health care, and 67.1% believe the government should provide tuition-free college. 

The negative association with the word ‘socialism,’ which American education and political forces upon young people, is beginning to fail as well. According to a 2019 Harris Poll, 61% of 18 to 24-year-old Americans have a positive association with the word socialism. Of these same respondents, only 58% said they had a positive association with the word ‘capitalism.’ 39% of the general population support socialism, making Gen Z and Millennials a notable change in attitude towards social democracy and socially democratic policies. This shift in public opinion demonstrates the real possibility of a new American dream, soon we will be the biggest voting bloc in the country.

Climate change: the last straw

An Amnesty International survey of 18 to 24-year-olds asked respondents to identify the most important issue from a list, 41% said climate change. The majority of our generation will not be 30 by the time the global temperature rises 1.5 degrees Celsius. That is a figure which scientists estimate is the highest increase in temperature which might not cause ecosystem collapse but will cause severe ocean acidification, mass desertification, and all coastal cities becoming flooded and uninhabitable. Only 100 profit-seeking, corporate or state-owned entities, are responsible for 71% of the devastation we begin to face. There is an “absolute tension” between short-term profitability, which capitalism encourages us to seek, and the need to reduce emissions. Fossil fuel companies choose profit over the common good every time. This reality is exemplified in the combined 2 trillion dollars these companies have invested in coal, oil, and gas projects which would be worthless if serious international action were taken to combat climate change.

Why are fossil fuel companies so confident their investments will be profitable? Capitalism stunts government action. As Phil McDuff wrote for the Guardian, “This is reality v the vested interests of capital. Any meaningful policy has to upset the established power base and the political donor class.” In other words, as long as the political class has an interest in fossil fuels, and receives donations, and support from others who are similarly invested in the success of this industry, the crisis will continue.

The end of predictable upward mobility for the abstract ‘middle-class’ American encourages young people to seek answers beyond capitalism in a system appealing only to those who currently own or are soon to own capital, not to those who remain, workers, all their lives. The climate crisis, by contrast, demands that young people abandon capitalism.

The American dream, for most, was a fiction. Now, many of those who may profit from the system see this future disappear. Maybe, this is the basis for the formation of a real, social-democratic American dream.

 

 


 

Donate

Comments

Find us at

Twitter Facebook Instagram RSS Flipboard

Share This Article!

Like this article?

Tags

American Dream Climate Change Capitalism Socialism Social Mobility

Related stories

Why Is Everything So White In The U.S.?

Why Is Everything So White In The U.S.?

 “Why is everything so white in America?” , Muhammed Ali asked in 1971 on the BBC show, Parkinson. He reflected on how whiteness played a huge role in everything and listed examples of the prominence of Whiteness…

Read more trending_flat
GOYA CEO's Praise Of Trump Is Seen As A Betrayal Of Hispanics

GOYA CEO's Praise Of Trump Is Seen As A Betrayal Of Hispanics

On Thursday, CEO and President of Goya Foods Bob Unanue, praised Donald Trump for his work with the economy at a White House event, stating "We're all truly blessed… to have a leader like President Trump, who is a builder.”  Amidst…

Read more trending_flat
Feminists’ Fight For Bodily Autonomy Should Be Anti-Capitalist

Feminists’ Fight For Bodily Autonomy Should Be Anti-Capitalist

When President Trump became the 45th President of the United States, his Department of Health and Human services changed Obama-era policy to allow publicly-traded companies to opt-out of providing no-cost birth control to women, if…

Read more trending_flat
If I Face Deportation From The U.S. I Would Have Nowhere To Go

If I Face Deportation From The U.S. I Would Have Nowhere To Go

Immigrations and Customs Enforcement announced on Monday that F1 and M1 visa holders — most international students — must leave the U.S. if their schools are online for the Fall semester. Students at schools with a hybrid…

Read more trending_flat
What “Cancel Culture” Reflects Upon From The Open Letter By Writers And Academics

What “Cancel Culture” Reflects Upon From The Open Letter By Writers And Academics

The beginning of the letter penned by the mass of prominent names in academia and writing reads as follows, “this needed reckoning has also intensified a new set of moral attitudes and political commitments that tend to weaken…

Read more trending_flat
The Case For A Universal Public Defender Program

The Case For A Universal Public Defender Program

In 2017, an interviewer asked Patrick J. Nolan, the director of the Criminal Justice Project at the American Conservative Union, about the chronic lack of funding for the public defender system. Nolan explained “it’s an…

Read more trending_flat

Latest article

Top